Posts

Showing posts with the label Marxism

Ways of Contradiction

Ways of Contradiction An Introduction to the Practice of Dialectic 1. Dialectic as the movement of contradiction In dialectical thought, definitions are often a problem. Definitions imply that terms have a single, stable meaning. Dialectical thought focuses on change, including changes in the meaning of the terms we use and the instability that makes such change possible. [1] At the same time, preliminary definitions are clearly helpful for anyone encountering the field of dialectic for the first time. Even for those familiar with the field, definitions indicate how terms are to be understood in a specific text. So, I begin with a few basic definitions, and a warning that they serve as no more than starting points, or as points of orientation in a landscape that changes as we travel through it. First, a dialectical process is a process characterized by the movement of contradictions—above all, the contradictions within specific system of ideas or forms of consciousness, or within spec...

The Double Lives of South African Marxism

The Double Lives of South African Marxism The Implosion of South African Marxism In April 1986, Paul Sweezy and Harry Magdoff (1986a) introduced a special issue of Monthly Review by describing the struggle against apartheid as ‘crucial to the whole history of our time.’ [i] South Africa was unique, they argued, because: It is so far the only country with a well-developed, modern capitalist structure which is not only objectively ripe for revolution but has actually entered a stage of overt and seemingly irreversible revolutionary struggle. . . . There is no other country in the world that has anything like the material and symbolic significance of South Africa for both sides of the conflict that rends the world today. A victory for revolution, i.e., a genuine and lasting change in basic power relations in South Africa, could have an impact on the balance of global forces comparable to that of the revolutionary wave that followed World War II. On the other hand, a victory for counter-r...